Menu of Lickety Split in East Greenbush, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Located at 589 Columbia Turnpike in East Greenbush, NY, Lickety Split is a standout ice cream shop that effortlessly blends quality, variety, and swift service. From the moment you approach, it feels like a classic drive-in with a modern twist—offering more than 24 flavors that cater to every craving.

The true showstoppers here are the Banana Split and the Cotton Candy flavors. The banana split lives up to its legendary status, with perfectly ripe bananas, rich ice cream scoops, and toppings that balance sweetness and texture flawlessly. Meanwhile, the cotton candy flavor is a whimsical journey back to the carnival, light yet creamy, capturing the essence of spun sugar without overwhelming the palate.

One cannot overlook the impressively thick and creamy texture of their soft serve, which discerning customers have praised for its stiffness and resilience in warm weather. Unlike other soft serves that quickly melt away, Lickety Split's offerings hold their shape, allowing you to savor every bite. The generous portion sizes add to the value, making it a fulfilling treat.

I was particularly impressed by the warm caramel topping paired with vanilla ice cream, which transformed into luscious ribbons that stretched and melded with the cold base, creating a delightful contrast of temperatures and textures that lingered in the memory. Such attention to detail in flavor pairing elevates the ice cream beyond a simple dessert to a compelling sensory experience.

The menu’s variety extends beyond cones and dishes to include malt milkshakes that are as rich as they are refreshing, adding another layer for those seeking a cool beverage with a creamy punch. The frequent rotation of specialty flavors ensures there’s always something new to explore, encouraging repeat visits.

While the setup emphasizes quick takeaway service—with a few outdoor benches rather than indoor seating—the efficiency of the staff keeps the line moving swiftly, even during peak summer heat. The added charm of kid-friendly mechanic-style rides makes it a welcoming destination for families.

It’s worth noting that this is a cash-only venue, albeit with an ATM on-site, so come prepared. The bustling atmosphere speaks volumes about the community’s affection for Lickety Split, reinforcing its reputation as a rare gem in the ice cream scene.

In essence, Lickety Split offers more than just ice cream—it delivers a well-crafted, nostalgic, and refreshing experience that compels you to return. Whether you favor classic banana splits, crave cotton candy sweetness, or want a sturdy, thick soft serve that stands up to the summer heat, this shop sets the standard high.